
Introduction.
Over the past few weeks, I’ve written about varroa and the possibilities of reducing reliance on chemical treatments. Northern Bee Books have just published Paul Honigmann’s timely manual on how to care for honey bees using low intervention management strategies, and relying on their natural resistance to varroa to protect them. I reviewed this textbook recently and learned a lot myself. Apart from being a really useful “how to” manual on practical beekeeping, it gives a comprehensive account of how and what to learn from watching a colony from the hive entrance. There are a few typos for correction when the book is reprinted, otherwise the information is laid out well and easy to read. You can listen to an interview with the author here: https://youtu.be/5jcB4j__xDA?si=-PukJBm89aXBYo74
Review.
Title: The Observant Beekeeper: A Practical Manual Treatment free, low intervention
Author: Paul Honigmann
Publisher: Northern Bee Books, 2024
ISBN: 978-1-914934-85-8
Softback, 404 pages, almost A4 size
Cost: £45
Available: Northern Bee Books and other bookstores.
The Observant Beekeeper: A Practical Manual Treatment free, low intervention by Paul Honigmann is a timely publication for the many experienced and new beekeepers currently seeking to change their management strategies and align their styles more closely with an environmentally aware, and minimal handling approach. This detailed “how to” manual offers ways to successfully reduce invasive colony manipulations and chemical treatments. It enables a beekeeper to look after honey bees in a mindful way that works in tandem with their natural biology and behaviour. It is the first of its kind in the UK and a valuable contribution to beekeeping education.
Honigmann is an experienced beekeeper with a passion for learning all he can about bees and sharing his knowledge with others. He started the Oxfordshire Natural Beekeeping Group which is a support system for alternative beekeepers. It was originally a local self-help group but has grown to provide regular blog posts and support beekeepers across the world,https://oxnatbees.wordpress.com/.
This book is based on teaching material used in the author’s beginner beekeeping classes and focusses on self-directed learning and promoting independent thinking and decision making. Review boxes at the end of most chapters invite the reader to summarise thoughts and make notes.
There are 18 chapters divided into 3 parts covering how to get started, a beekeeper’s year, and further reflections on health, genetics, and current beekeeping challenges. The price reflects the nature of this publication which is an intricately produced textbook jam-packed full of valuable information presented in an easy-to-read format enhanced by at least 400 diagrams, drawings, tables, and photographs. Around 400 footnotes and references are found at the bottom of each page and reflect the author’s wide scientific research which backs up advice and explanations. Many of the references are based on anecdotal evidence but this is a good thing because it draws on the collective intelligence of other experienced and well-known beekeepers which endorses credibility.
There are many different ways to keep honey bees such as conventional beekeeping where the emphasis is on manipulating colonies for honey production, (varroa) treatment-free, or natural beekeeping. Honigmann is clear, “Observational Beekeeping is not specific to one system.” He is open to all beekeeping systems and is a current member of the British Beekeeper’s Association (BBKA) whose teaching is largely conventional, but they too are open to finding new ways to reduce the reliance on chemical treatments for varroosis. The BBKA will be interested in this new textbook, and its value on their recommended reading list for new beekeepers.
What makes this textbook stand out from others is the concise clear explanations and reasons for carrying out procedures with the pros and cons for each considered. This encourages new beekeepers to think for themselves and make decisions based on their own conclusions. There are no rigid rules to be followed. It is written in the modern style for the busy reader who wants to reach the salient points quickly. Honigmann uses clear headings, lists, and bullet points.
As the title implies, this style of beekeeping is about spending more time watching a colony from outside the hive rather than opening it up frequently to look through all the frames. It is also about acknowledging the differences among colonies and letting them work at their own paces throughout the season. It is acknowledged that this is not something bee farmers are likely to have much time for owing to the sheer volume of their work. This is not about honey production or queen breeding which is well covered in other publications.
The chapters on hive types, and the detailed management required for each type, are particularly useful. Having tried a few different hive types, Honigmann writes from practical experience giving lucid explanations for new beekeepers bamboozled by lists and photographs of different types. Honigmann discusses hive thermodynamics and recent research. 25% of colony heat is lost in winter through the open mesh floor but this can be mitigated by closing it and adding foil insulation below the roof. Did you know that top bee space can increase thermal loss by 70%?
The rationale for not clipping queen’s wings is reasonable, practical, and unemotional. Wing clipping usually results in prime swarms with multiple virgin queens which are less cohesive and consequently less successful. There are many useful tips and pieces of advice that everyone can learn from in this textbook. Do you know what a Russian scion is? I didn’t till now but I’m going to make one for next swarm season.
The reasons behind not selecting for particular traits in queen breeding are worthy of considerable reflection. One cannot select for all desirable traits, and by selecting for prolific laying, for example, the beekeeper ends up with queens that do not turn off egg laying during a dearth. These colonies are less adaptable and have to be boosted and fed by the beekeeper and are thus not allowed the freedom to survive by nature of their own genes.
The Observant Beekeeper is for everyone with an interest in making beekeeping easier for themselves and the bees, and for those interested in learning how bees were kept in the days before varroa. The author has achieved his goals and a new beekeeper could start from scratch using only this comprehensive manual.
Thank you, Ann, for providing a thorough description of Paul Honigmann’s book in your review of it. Given the book’s size and price, I had decided to not purchase a copy, but after learning more about it through your review, I have decided to purchase a copy.
Thank you, Tom, for the positive feedback.
Thank you for posting, and for your positive comments Oxnatbees.